day leading up to the premiere on Wednesday, Jan. 19, we will post a
retrospective on each season. We’re breaking it down into four
categories: Best Performance, Worst Performance, Most Underrated Idol
and most Overrated Idol. At the end, we will decide how the season
stacks up against the rest, rating it as great, good, or not-so-good.
Season 4 contestants in order of elimination:
Carrie Underwood (winner)
Best Performance: Carrie Underwood, “Alone,” Bo Bice “Vehicle” (tie)
Bo and Carrie might be our favorite top 2 every on “Idol.” They were both very talented and fun to watch. These performances really defined their season — we still have both of these actual performances on on our iPod and listening to them now, they still give us chills.
Worst Performance: Mikalah Gordon, “Love Will Lead You Back,” Anthony Fedorov, “Climb Ev’ry Mountain” (tie)
Mikalah Gordon’s Fran Drescher schtick really annoyed us and her voice was so unusual that it really only worked with certain songs. Taylor Dayne’s “Love Will Lead You Back” was not one of them. On the flip side, we really liked Anthony Fedorov’s voice. But this Mother Superior ballad from “The Sound of Music” was not good.
Most Underrated Idol: Nadia Turner
We thought Nadia could’ve advanced beyond Anwar, Constantine and Scott. She was hard-core and could really wail. She made the mohawk cool way before stupid Sanjaya came along. We loved her “You Don’t Have to Say You Love Me” and “Time After Time.”
Most Overrated Idol: Scott Savol and Constantine Maroulis
We could not figure out how Scott stayed in the competition as long as he did — we didn’t think he could sing a lick. Constantine, while being able to sing (his “My Funny Valentine” was excellent), made us feel icky. All the time.
How the season stacks up: Great
Season 4 not only launched arguably the most successful Idol in Carrie Underwood, but it had a number of very talented singers and was extremely fun to watch.