We love how Casey James gets to rock out on the guitar during the “It’s My Life” group number — but we aren’t huge fans of the vocals. There’s a reason all these people were in a singing competition for soloists, not groups.
The cover of “My Life Would Suck Without You” gets a little better, but we still aren’t sold. And we were fans of Season 9. Perhaps there’s just something painful about the group numbers? What do you guys think? Thumbs up on the “GMA” performance?