During his performance of “I Put A Spell On You” after being eliminated on Apr. 29, Casey did nothing to deny the rumors when he sang the last line of the song — “Because you’re mine” — looking directly into Haley’s eyes while holding onto her shoulders. In an exit interview with the press, Casey talked about his last performance and whether or not he’s actually dating Haley.
“I was saying goodbye to my very special musical friend,” Casey says of serenading Haley at the end of his performance. “I didn’t plan on ending up on Haley. It just happened that way. Nothing was planned.”
When asked if he and Haley are currently dating, Casey answers, “No, we are not.” Later, the bass-playing crooner was asked if the two were ever romantically involved during the show, which Casey denied as well: “We were never dating.”
And there you have it, “Idol” fans. Bummed that these two aren’t dating? Sound off in the comments.