psych-james-roday-dule-hill-USA.jpg“Psych” said goodbye with “The Break-Up” Wednesday (March 26), which star Dule Hill tells Zap2it opens up a whole new world for a possible follow-up movie. But after the episode aired, the cast assembled for a live “After Pshow” on USA.

It was adorable to watch the cast members reminisce, but the best part was a game they made the actors play where they had to answer questions about each other to see who got the most votes for various superlatives:

Biggest potty mouth: Tim Omundson
Biggest freak-out over a lost cell phone: Dule Hill (“I’m a Tweet-aholic,” says Hill)
Whose trailer do you least like to visit: Corbin Bernsen (“It smells,” says Kirsten Nelson)
Most likely to bring dog to set: James Roday, Maggie Lawson and Tim Omundson tied

There were also some terrific messages from past guest stars: Ralph Macchio, Corbin Bleu, Cary Elwes, Nestor Carbonell, Lori Loughlin, Steve Howey, Rachael Leigh Cook, James Brolin, Judd Nelson and Jaleel White.

It was a fun reunion, but we were really hoping we’d hear some news about the “Psych” movie. Ah well. Fingers crossed for some future news.