Jimmy Fallon had Charlize Theron on “The Tonight Show” Tuesday (May 20) to promote her new movie, “A Million Ways to Die in the West,” but after her interview, he enlisted her for a game of charades with “Penny Dreadful” star Josh Hartnett.

Hilariously, neither Hartnett nor Theron can get “Private Dancer.” Fallon laments that they’re both too young to really know that song. We call shenanigans on that one, c’mon — who doesn’t know “Private Dancer”?

Below, Theron talks her recent hosting gig on “Saturday Night Live” and about her son’s obsession with Tinker Bell, which is adorable.

“A Million Ways to Die in the West” is in theaters Friday, May 30.